The right to selfdetermination has become one of the most complex issues for u. Interests and possible policy options 7 conclusion 18 about the author 19 about the institute 20 contents. The uk was more ambiguous on the relevance of territorial integrity in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination, arguing that territory is important in defining the people, but it does not require that the boundaries of the territory remain entirely unchanged during some unspecified period prior to independence. Selfdetermination as a human right peace palace library. You are forgetting the right of first nations to selfdetermination wendake, april 10, 2019 after the national assembly passed a motion on the territorial integrity of quebec, the chief of the assembly of first nations quebeclabrador afnql, mr. The principles of territorial integrity and self determination are two important principles which apply to international law and politics. In fact, these two segments have been and remain intrinsic to every discussion of selfdetermination. Selfdetermination within the territory of former yugoslavia 249. Territorial integrity is the principle under international law that prohibits states from the use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of another state. This book offers a comprehensive, highly informative and interdisciplinary study on territorial integrity and the challenges globalization, self determination and external interventions present. Interests and possible policy options 7 conclusion 18 about the author 19 about the institute 20. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it.
The evolution of discussions about the karabakh conflict between armenia and azerbaijan over the last 15 years provides some important lessons about the complex and evolving interrelationship of two principles of international law. The principle of territorial integrity as applied to the rights of subgroups of an existing. This study analyzes the issue of selfdetermination, territorial integrity and international stability, within the yugoslav context. The right to selfdetermination and international law nzlii. The first is closely connected with a basic order in interstate relations, while the second is a fundamental human right. Selfdetermination, territorial integrity and fait accompli in. To maintain international peace and security, and to that end. Keywords selfdetermination remedial secession territorial integrity crimea russian federation this article is partly based on the authors phd thesis entitled remedial secession. Because selfdetermination encompasses so many issues including individual and minority rights, regional autonomy, government repression, territorial integrity, state sovereignty, and claims to independence, to name but a fewthe most difficult task in planning such a meeting was to determine which aspects of the issue would be addressed. Sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of selfdetermination balraj puri vol. Territorial integrity and the right to selfdetermination. How does the international community reconcile the. This book offers a comprehensive, highly informative and interdisciplinary study on territorial integrity and the challenges globalization, selfdetermination and external interventions present.
In addition, self determination is viewed in connection with two other issues. Self determination sovereignty,territorial integrity, and. Tension between the competing principles of territorial integrity and self. This has usually been considered solely in relation to the territorial integrity of an existing state seeking to resist claims by peoples for the right to selfdetermination. Territorial integrity and selfdetermination of nations are two principles of the international law, which raise a lot of debates because of a supposed contradiction. An examination of the conceptual tools joshua castellino follow this and additional works at. Purposes and principles article 1the purposes of the united nations are. Because self determination encompasses so many issues including individual and minority rights, regional autonomy, government repression, territorial integrity, state sovereignty, and claims to independence, to name but a fewthe most difficult task in planning such a meeting was to determine which aspects of the issue would be addressed.
The anglophone problem in cameroon has been an everpresent issue of social, political and economic debates in the country, albeit most times in. The present report provides the view of the government of the republic of azerbaijan on the interrelationship between the legal norm of the territorial integrity of states and the principle of selfdetermination in international law in the context of. A territorial interpretation lea brilmayert the phrase selfdeterminationis simply loaded with dyna mite. The principles of territorial integrity and self determination are integral parts of the international law. Together with the concept of nonintervention, territorial integrity is significant to the evolution of the principles associated with the maintenance of international peace and security. Jun 27, 2018 selfdetermination and territorial integrity paul joffe1 27 june 2018 international law makes clear that all peoples have the right of selfdetermination.
Contrast between right to selfdetermination and territorial integrity preservation in international law hassan kouzehgar1 2mohsen vaseqi 1,2department of law, payame noor university pnu, tehran, i. Exceptions to the right to self determination 38 ii. Historical development of selfdetermination and territorial integrity policy and lawmakers have long grappled with differing interpretations of selfdetermination and territorial integrity, either as enshrined postulate of international or customary law,3or as ambiguous theory of international relations. Yet the chagos opinion by the international court of justice examines a different type of territorial integritythat of the colonial territory itself. African states and institutions believe that the principle of territorial integrity is applicable to substate groups and limits their right to self determination, contrary to international law. Section one addresses the development and codification of the law on self determination, including the identification of the current. Pdf this paper explores the ambiguous nature of two principles of international law selfdetermination and territorial integrity illustrating the. Territorial integrity and selfdetermination european leadership. Contrast between right to self determination and territorial integrity preservation in international law hassan kouzehgar1 2mohsen vaseqi 1,2department of law, payame noor university pnu, tehran, i. This thesis examines selfdetermination as a human right, focusing on the central question whether international law allows for a right of external selfdetermination in the form of. The principles of territorial integrity and selfdetermination are integral parts of the international law. National self determination appears to challenge the principle of territorial integrity or sovereignty of states as it is the will of the people that makes a state legitimate. Pdf how does the international community reconcile the. False dilemmas, double standards and the quest for positive law 76 ii.
See generally lea brilmayer, secession and self determination. In fact, these two segments have been and remain intrinsic to every discussion of self determination. The importance of these principles is enormous in the international community. A conflict between territorial integrity and secession. This paper explores the ambiguous nature of two principles of international law selfdetermination and territorial integrity illustrating the controversial nuances of international law on a political level, nuances with which the crimean crisis has been described. See, also, the reference manual of the conference on security.
Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession. Territorial integrity also underlines the decentralized state. A right to external selfdetermination as a remedy to serious injustices. States and the right to selfdetermination in the light of armenias revisionist claims 1. Territorial integrity and selfdetermination dialnet. At the same time, the international system, particularly in the postworld war ii era, has steadfastly defended the inviolability of existing nationstates borders. A territorial interpretation lea brilmayert the phrase self determination is simply loaded with dyna mite. As a norm of international law, it protects the territorial framework of the independent state and is an essential foundation of the sovereignty of states. Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to. No right of external selfdetermination beyond the context of decolonization 80 1.
Legal definitions and obligations 8 5 a specific case. International treaty bodies have repeatedly concluded this. External selfdetermination and the saltwater test 81 2. See generally lea brilmayer, secession and selfdetermination. Revista destudis autonomics i federals, num 16, octubre 2012. The kosovo crisis in an international law perspective. The legal issues involved in the western sahara dispute. Dec 11, 20 urrutia, inigo, territorial integrity and selfdetermination. Selfdetermination in disputed colonial territories. Self determination sovereignty,territorial integrity. Urrutia, inigo, territorial integrity and selfdetermination.
That is why outside the colonial context, the emphasis must be on the internal aspect of selfdetermination. Section one addresses the development and codification of the law on. Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession carley, patricia. To ascertain the manner in which the legal treatment of territory affects groups seeking self determination, this article seeks to identify the international legal regime that governs the treatment of territory, race its evt o. Sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of self. It has been accepted for inclusion in brooklyn journal of.
African states and institutions believe that the principle of territorial integrity is applicable to substate groups and limits their right to selfdetermination, contrary to international law. This study aims at not only to fill an epistemological gap in this regard, but also answer the question of whether international law is adequately. On the meaning of restoring indigenous selfdetermination 11 the principle of equal rights and selfdetermination of peoples, and to take other appropriate. Dec 30, 2018 however, all three territorial arrangements referred to in this paper could be affected by the outcome of the chagos advisory proceedings, especially if the icj considers it necessary to flesh out the content and scope of the law on self determination and territorial integrity. Territorial integrity refers to the protection of an independent states territory from aggression of other states. It sets the problem of secession under two contradictory and mutually exclusive options, neither of which is true as such under positive international law. Selfdetermination, territorial integrity and fait accompli. These principles define the relationships which a country should have with others especially regarding global politics. Liechtenstein was convinced that, if applied in a meaningful way, the right to selfdetermination could contribute to stability and to preserving the territorial integrity of states.
It is recognized that the principle of self determination has a universal realization 17 and the obligations rising from the principle of self determination are. How does the international community reconcile the principles. Self determination is defined as a right of nations to freely decide their sovereignty and political status without external compulsion or outside interference 2, p. The choice between selfdetermination and territorial integrity is one of the oldest false dilemmas of international law. Territorial integrity refers to the territorial oneness or wholeness of the state. Territorial integrity in international law its concept. January 2006 vladimir putin said that the selfdetermination of kosovo could be used as a precedent by abkhazia and south. This implies a people should be free to choose their own state and its territorial boundaries. You are forgetting the right of first nations to selfdetermination wendake, april 10, 2019 after the national assembly passed a motion on the territorial integrity of quebec, the chief of the assembly of first nations quebeclabrador.
The architects of the yalta 3 this case was invoked in president putins crimea speech 18 march 2014. Pdf unresolved claims to selfdetermination are among the biggest challenges in global politics today. Summary v preface ix 1 introduction 1 2 a history of the self determination concept 3 3 the rise of contemporary self determination movements 5 4 the self determination principle. Selfdetermination, territorial integrity and fait accompli in the case of crimea theodore christakis abstract 75 i.
Another difficulty of conceding the right of selfdetermination in the sense of independence is in the case of identities which have no territorial base. The choice between self determination and territorial integrity is one of the oldest false dilemmas of international law. Selfdetermination and territorial integrity in the chagos. It is recognized that the principle of selfdetermination has a universal realization 17 and the obligations rising from the principle of selfdetermination are. Historical development of self determination and territorial integrity policy and lawmakers have long grappled with differing interpretations of self determination and territorial integrity, either as enshrined postulate of international or customary law,3or as ambiguous theory of international relations. The present report provides the view of the government of the republic of azerbaijan on the interrelationship between the legal norm of the territorial integrity of states and the principle of selfdetermination in. The approach of the international court of justice in the advisory opinion on kosovo october 9, 2012.
Given that the boundaries of identity and community. However, it is not confined to the yugoslav case of selfdetermination alone. Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the right to secession united states institute of peace. Would there still be the urge for selfdetermination if people are able to get this freedom. This chapter discusses the concept of territorial integrity, an important principle founded upon the concept of a sovereign and independent state. Territorial integrity in a globalizing world springerlink. This article is brought to you for free and open access by the law journals at brooklynworks. Conversely it states that imposition by force of a border change is an act of aggression. Ghislain picard, reminds us that indigenous peoples have the.
197 334 1340 496 4 620 853 468 1170 1092 451 871 808 326 261 968 436 186 378 1435 929 1419 1254 1128 1028 220 401 328